I have NEVER seen it work any other way.

If its function was to not....then it works....

Jafo, really, it has always been blank, and you mark it if you want to subscribe. Now, it automatically subscribes you if you reply. You unsubscribe, reply again, you're subscribed again. It has never worked that way before.

Oops.

Nope...for me it has always been ticked.

I'm sure Bastards Inc. simply had it in for me from Day One ....

I was like that when the "feature" was first introduced. Then enough people complained and they changed it to un checked by default. I COULD try to find the thread.......

Well what do you know, Looks like it was ME who brought it up last time: https://forums.wincustomize.com/443673

2 thirds ..... if you managed to get it fixed it lasted around 5 minutes or so....and happily went back to 'normal'...

I'm checked everywhere also. It doesn't bother me.     I don't even bother unchecking...   

Well, I must be a curmudgeon. I hope they fix it. Having to manually uncheck things, or settle for having a shitload of unwanted subscriptions is a royal pain in the ass.

Please fix it......please.....lol...waaaaa....  

Subscribing to a post should be a decision made by the user, not the site coding. Is anybody going to take user complaints seriously on this? It's been brought up before, so please just take care of it, it is not a joking matter. 

Well said, Tom. 

It will serve to limit my activity in the forum if I have to remember to uncheck a box every time I reply to a thread.

I'll have to agree with that as well, 2of3.  It's a pain in the sacroiliac to have to uncheck it every time.

Sorry, you are wrong. It was (as indicated in the thread I linked to) changed to un-checked by default. It's only recently gone back to checked by default.

And we'd like it fixed.

Please.